The Innovation Graveyard: Startups That Were Too Early to Succeed

By David Armaah

In the world of tech innovation, timing is everything. A brilliant idea launched at the wrong moment can fall flat, only to be resurrected years later by another startup or even a Big Tech giant, now basking in success.

Today, we revisit three recently fallen startups that may have been too early, too niche, or too bold. They’re not failures in the conventional sense – they were bets on the future. And in some cases, the future just wasn’t ready.

1. Forward – The AI-Powered “doctor in a box”

Founded: 2016
Shut down: November 2024
Raised: ~$225M

Forward set out to reinvent primary care through sleek, AI-powered “CarePods” – self-service medical booths placed in malls and public spaces. Users could measure vitals, perform diagnostic tests, and receive instant recommendations — all without interacting with a human doctor.

Why it failed:
The tech overpromised and underdelivered. Blood draws malfunctioned, UV sterilization lights glitched, and vital readings were inconsistent. The pods were expensive to operate and maintain, and adoption lagged. In healthcare, anything short of clinical-grade performance isn’t just annoying — it’s dangerous.

Could it work today?
The vision still makes sense: remote-first, data-driven care with minimal overhead. But it will take a new generation of hardware, better UX, and much stronger public trust in AI to make it viable at scale.

What we learn:
In medicine, trust is earned through precision and reliability, not sleek design and ambition. You can’t beta test people’s health.

     2. Quibi – “Short-Form Streaming for the Smartphone Era”
Founded: 2018
Shut down: 2020
Raised: $1.75B (yes, billion)

Quibi (short for “quick bites”) was a mobile-first streaming platform designed for on-the-go viewing. The idea: we don’t just want to scroll TikTok or watch cat videos — we want HBO-quality, 10-minute cinematic stories. From top-tier Hollywood talent. Only on your phone.

Why it failed:
They launched during the pandemic, when nobody was commuting. But the real issue was distribution control and user behavior — you couldn’t screenshot shows, cast to your TV, or easily share. In a TikTok-Instagram world, that’s a death sentence. Also, they underestimated how much people actually like raw, user-generated content.

Could it work today?
The idea of high-quality, short-form content remains viable — and has been absorbed into other formats like YouTube Shorts and TikTok series. But tying a content platform strictly to mobile viewing and paid subscriptions may never gain traction in a post-Netflix world.

What we learn:
Distribution context matters. Users don’t just want content. They want culture, shareability, and control.

    3. Doppler Labs – “Hearables for a Smarter Listening Experience”
Founded: 2013
Shut down: 2017
Raised: $50M+

Before the AirPods Pro could whisper sweet nothings through your ears, Doppler Labs was building “Here One” earbuds with real-time language translation, ambient sound filtering, and voice interaction.

They weren’t just headphones; they were a wearable platform.

Why it failed:
The hardware was expensive to produce and tough to scale. The market wasn’t yet trained to think of earbuds as smart devices. Battery life, Bluetooth connectivity, and consumer expectations were all working against them. And Apple was quietly building its empire.

Could it work today?
Yes — and it is. Doppler’s vision is now alive in products from Apple, Google, and even AI-native wearables like Humane’s AI Pin and the Rabbit R1. The idea was solid. The ecosystem just didn’t exist yet.

What we learn:
Inventing a new category is tough, and being “first” isn’t enough. You also have to be the last one standing when the market finally gets it.

Final Thought: Are These Failures or Foreshadowing?

Innovation doesn’t always reward the trailblazer. Sometimes, the first to the summit gets buried in the snow, while someone else plants the flag later. The Innovation Graveyard isn’t just about failed companies; it’s about missed moments, premature brilliance, and the long arc of readiness.

Today’s discarded ideas might be tomorrow’s unicorns. All it takes is the right market, the right tech, and maybe just a little more time.

Get innovation insights from The FutureList weekly. Subscribe to our newsletter here